Out-of-form fast bowler Mitchell Johnson has become the lightning rod for Australian anger at the cherished national team's poor performance in the first Ashes Test against England, polarising opinion on his second Test selection chances.
Major newspapers opened online polls on Wednesday asking readers whether Johnson should keep his place for the second Test, which starts at the Adelaide Oval on Friday. After almost 2,500 votes, 85 percent of respondents believed the tall left-armer should be dropped.
Opinion was even divided along family lines as brothers Ian and Greg Chappell - both former captains of the Australian cricket team - found themselves on opposite sides of the argument.
National selector Greg Chappell told reporters he wasn't worried about Johnson's current form - he ended the first Test with figures of nought for 170 - though he refused to guarantee the paceman's re-selection.
Australia has already moved to replace Johnson if necessary by including fast bowlers Ryan Harris and Doug Bollinger in its 13-man second Test squad.
"Worried is not a word I would use," Greg Chappell said. "We obviously recognise he's not in the peak of form at the moment so we're keen to see him back to that as soon as possible.
"Players go through ups and downs in various stages of their careers. He's still one of our key bowlers."
Television cricket analyst Ian Chappell was quoted by Australian newspapers as saying Johnson appeared by the end of the first Test to have lost all confidence.
"So I'm not sure you can take him into Adelaide. That's one change they've got to make," he said.
Australia coach Tim Nielsen has also been reluctant to lay blame for his team's moderate performance in Brisbane at Johnson's feet, or to discount the possibility of his selection in Adelaide.
"At different times there have been a lot of players who haven't performed in one Test match and then have come out and upped the ante," he said. "There were times when we let it get away (in Brisbane), not as an individual but as a bowling group, and when that happens, one guy usually gets exposed; Mitch is the one we're talking about."
Nielsen said the coaches were working with the whole bowling group to prepare everybody for another test match.
"We've got to make sure Mitch is relaxed and thinking clearly about what works for him," he said.
Former South African coach Mickey Arthur, who coaches Johnson's Western Australian state side, called for the fast bowler to be spared.
"There's no doubt he should stay in the side," Arthur said. "Mitchell Johnson is in the top five quicks in the world.
"I come from a South African dressing room who rate Mitchell Johnson extremely highly. Mitchell Johnson has got that ability to change a Test match in a session. He's that type of player.
"To leave him out would certainly be premature, in my opinion, because he's the one potential match-winner Australia have. For him to get that criticism right now is pretty harsh."
Stuart Clark, the spearhead of Australia's attack in its 2006 Ashes series against England, also offered Johnson support.
"I am not sure leaving Mitch out of the Adelaide Test is the best option at present, but I can guarantee you that a selector coming out and stating that he is on borrowed time will not help," Clark wrote in a column in the Sydney Morning Herald.
Johnson has failed to take a wicket in four of his past five Test innings and has taken just three wickets in those matches at a cost of 122.3.
Clark said Johnson had obviously lost confidence and "only wickets will banish the demons from within."
Former selector Merv Hughes believed criticism of Johnson was overly harsh and that the pitch on offer in Adelaide would benefit the under-fire pace ace far more than the Gabba track did.
"Adelaide is probably going to suit Mitchell Johnson a little bit better than Brisbane because it sort of slides on, his extra pace is going to be useful. I think we are just starting to get too critical," Hughes told Melbourne radio station SEN.
"We are starting to expect a lot from a young man that, yes, he has got talent, but really hasn't matured or developed into the cricketer that he can be. And by cutting him short, and leaving him out of this Test match, it's going to dent his confidence more than anything else."




Your Comments
jack
As much as it would be nice to give Johnson another chance to prove himself, let us not forget that this is the Ashes we are talking about, and the score is 0-0 at the moment and both sides are vying for the upper hand. Drastic action needs to be taken if Australia are going to compete. Johnson should be dropped immediately, and told to go back to the drawing board and get things in gear again and then return, maybe for the fourth or fifth test. In the meantime, Bollinger should step in, and also Hauritz should replace Doherty. He has more experience, and will succeed for sure.