Cricket is great; we won’t save the game by telling everyone it isn’t
The latest ECB marketing wheeze for The Hundred has Dave Tickner banging his head on the desk in frustration. We must stop apologising for our great sport and start showing some faith in the game.
“Root and Stokes will be allocated to a team for marketing purposes, but they won’t be playing. The ECB made the point that this new audience won’t necessarily know who Stokes and Root are anyway.”
Now, we’ve all had our fun with The Hundred, the ECB’s half-baked, arse-witted attempt at a Not-Quite Twenty20 tournament. But this is next-level stuff.
The concept of The Hundred is the only thing in the world more stupid than the surely fictitious mouth-breathing thickos it’s apparently being condescendingly aimed at. It’s surely medically impossible for anyone to be simultaneously as thick as the ECB thinks millions of mums and kids are while still continuing to breathe in and out or remembering to eat.
The astonishing quote at the top (delivered by a messenger, Worcestershire batsman and PCA shop steward Daryl Mitchell, who it should be stated for the record does not in any way deserve to be shot; none of this is his fault) represents a new peak in 2018 cricketing stupidity. And remember 2018 is the year that Australia banned its best player for a whole year just to make some already-abandoned point about standards and Australia’s elite exceptionalism.
Let’s look at it more closely, because it really is quite something. The ECB are going to allocate their most well-known players to teams in The Hundred, even though they won’t be playing in it, to help with the marketing. And – here’s the really clever part – It won’t matter that they don’t end up playing, because the audience won’t know who they are anyway…
SO WHY ALLOCATE THEM FOR MARKETING PURPOSES AT ALL? Sorry to shout, but this has got out of hand. When your latest big wheeze sounds precisely like it was cooked up by Siobhan Sharpe and could be lifted verbatim for David Tennant to narrate you’ve surely got to admit that the jig is up.
Big decisions (like adding a new format of cricket!) need to be well researched with all stakeholders before announcing it and have answers to the many questions that will crop up. If that is all done then it will gain support, if not, people will question why it is being done?
— Chris Nash (@chrisnash23) May 9, 2018
It’s become clear since the initial announcement that The Hundred is not only incredibly thick but also hasn’t been remotely thought through on the most basic practical level.
Genuinely, it would now be less embarrassing for the ECB if this whole thing turns out to have been a communication error, an internal memo accidentally announced to the world that they’ve gamely tried to make the best of. A “there are no bad ideas” brainstorming gag that got out of hand. The only other option I can think of, beyond the horrifying thought that they genuinely think this might be a good idea, is that it’s a nefarious, Machiavellian kind of Trojan Horse (or camel, perhaps) designed to sneak the city-based T20 past horrified county cricket fans. Convince them something as shitbone awful as The Hundred is coming along, and when ‘only’ a city-based T20 tournament arrives it suddenly looks like a blessed relief.
The official line out of the ECB remains that they genuinely think this will be good and simpler to follow than T20 and can bring a whole new audience of mums and kids to the game. The utter lack of evidence for this means people have looked elsewhere for other possible reasons.
There are two theories, and there is probably something in both. The ECB wanted a new tournament to rival the IPL and the Big Bash. To do it, they needed the counties on board. To get the counties on board they had to keep the old tournament as well. To keep the old tournament as well they needed a new format, even though the old tournament had precisely the ideal format for the new one.
So they’ve effectively hulled the new tournament before it leaves dock to protect the old tournament they didn’t really rate. Again, it sounds too stupid to be a thing that could actually happen until you consider the Root and Stokes wheeze. If the last few years have taught us nothing else, it’s that this is precisely a stupid enough thing to happen.
Whether as a by-product of this or an additional driver of the concept there is the apparent happiness of broadcasters with a slightly shorter format more easily inserted into a free-to-air TV channel’s schedules.
At this point, it’s hard not to take some slight pyrrhic pleasure at the fact that those most ideologically opposed to The Hundred are exactly those most likely to champion the need for cricket to be on FTA and, specifically, BBC television.
But that fleeting joy won’t get us anywhere.
If the ECB really are happy to let marketeers piss about so fundamentally with the sport just to get it on FTA while simultaneously congratulating themselves on the fact that people don’t know who Joe Root and Ben Stokes are, then the sport in this country has even bigger problems than any of us realised.
Cricket – and specifically cricket in England here – needs to stop apologising for being so complicated and impenetrable. It really isn’t a uniquely complex sport, no matter what whimsical tea-towels have to say on the matter.
Cricket, like all great sports, begins with a deceptively simple concept beyond which is as much depth and complexity as its follower wishes to uncover in pursuit of understanding.
If cricket has one problem (if that’s the right word) in terms of opacity, it is the inability to objectively answer the question “Who’s winning?” until the final moment. The Hundred does nothing to remedy this anyway, and it is in any case part of the game’s great appeal once you’re sucked in. It’s the reason why DLS and PredictViz and WASP and the like exist; all of them elaborate but imperfect attempts to answer a riddle that can be solved with a simple glance at the corner of the screen in all other team sports.
If the BBC can commit to 17 days of live snooker from a darkened room in Sheffield, where matches can run to 10 hours with no concrete end time, cricket should feel secure enough in its own skin not to rip up its fundamentals to get the same treatment. If tennis, with its own idiosyncratic scoring system and lack of mainstream appeal, can get a month of Auntie’s undivided attention every summer, then cricket should feel confident enough to deserve the same. If the BBC can show Every. Single. Stone of every GB curling match at the Winter Olympics then… maybe cricket shouldn’t even want to be on the BBC at all. And let’s not even start on the Royal Wedding.
The point is this. The most worrying thing about The Hundred is not that it’s a rubbish idea; it’s that it shows just what a low opinion those who run cricket in this country have of the sport.
Cricket is not impossibly complicated or impenetrable. The general public are not too stupid to understand it. We just constantly tell them that it is and they are, and then seem horrified to discover they believe it.
Olly Stone ready to ‘bash down the door’ after England recall
The Warwickshire paceman was included in the one-day international squad against South Africa and impressed in an intra-squad warm-up game.
Sam Billings striving to make sure he keeps place in ‘phenomenal’ England side
Billings and Joe Root put on 103 for Jos Buttler’s XI in a 40-over intra-squad warm-up victory in Cape Town.
Joe Root hits decisive 77 as Jos Buttler’s team triumph in England warm-up match
The 23-man squad was split in two for the 40-over practice match in Cape Town, with Team Eoin Morgan challenging Team Buttler.
Joe Root hits 77 as England warm-up in Cape Town ahead of South Africa series
England split their squad into two teams for a 40-over practice match.
Warm-up match cancelled after second Proteas player tests positive for COVID-19
There will be no intra-squad warm-up for the Proteas thanks to a COVID-19 outbreak.
Chris Jordan says South Africa should not be ‘judged’ for not taking a knee
Barbados-born Jordan says racial inequality remains a pressing matter among England’s diverse squad.
Lockie Ferguson prepared to wait for his Test break
Injury to Lockie Ferguson allowed Kyle Jamieson to seize his opportunity to impress Black Caps team management before lockdown.
ICC makes alterations to World Test Championship points system
COVID-19 has forced the ICC to amend the points system for the 2019-21 World Test Championship.
World leading Dawid Malan ready to prove himself again in South Africa
Yorkshire batsman has impressed in T20 cricket.
England captain Knight welcomes cricket’s return to Commonwealth Games
Cricket will return to the Commonwealth Games in 2022 with a Women’s T20 tournament.