Ellis: Cook must dare to be bold
Cricketing declarations can get a very bad press.
At one end of the extreme, think back to the Division One County Championship decider between Middlesex and Yorkshire at Lord’s in deepest September.
It stokes up visions of trailer trash bowling instigated by a classy toilet talk between the skippers. The implementation of the artificial construct (not the agreement itself) made a mockery of the game.
They must have been choking on their cider down in Taunton when those ‘hit me’ balls were being sent down by the Yorkshire opening pair Alex Lees and Adam Lyth.
In comparison, the conservatism of cricket’s Test captains can be as restrictive as a python squeeze. We live in a world where five day cricket is fighting against, but also fuelled, by the rise of Twenty20 and a general lack of patience in a speed dial schedule.
Declarations and four innings games appear an almost archaic throwback to former times where genteel decisions were taken by gentlemen over pipe-smoking dressing room committee.
Cricket has certainly tweaked its appeal ahead of that other time-consuming sport, golf. Test cricket is still the ultimate for purists but the thrill of the chase often never materialises.
Innate conservatism does not assist the longevity of the five day game. Take Alastair Cook’s miserable bunch of 2013 plodders, who joylessly won the Ashes series 3-0 but didn’t win many friends doing so.
In the prequel to the Ashes at home that summer, Cook’s declarations were insanely safe. He quit the second innings against New Zealand at Headingley a mere 467 ahead with an extremely dodgy fifth day forecast.
England just about squeaked the win in between the showers. It was painful to watch. There have been numerous examples since of an extreme safety first approach from the Essex man.
Rajkot was a more modest ‘mistake’ if that’s what it was. A target of 310 on a turning pitch with no fielding restrictions and a minimum of 49 overs to bowl was never going to be an option for an Indian XI who didn’t exactly fly out of the blocks in the first innings.
It just seems utterly senseless to leave such a declaration to the point where the mathematical improbability of the chase is about as likely as Michael Vaughan staying quiet for two minutes.
While Graeme Smith and Michael Clarke may not have been the most universally popular of skippers, neither of them were afraid to roll the dice. Both hated losing, but there’s a big difference.
Brendon McCullum was another one who saw possibilities of victory rather than getting the computer of probabilities to work it all out for him. As Bobby Simpson once said: “I’ve got my laptop,” pointing to his head. Cook admits a braver person would have gone for it.
The next logical step for Alastair and his army is to advance without the comfort zones that are constantly holding the team back. Now that Adil Rashid has shown his hand, he should be given more trust.
One gets the feeling that despite the many positives of the first Test, England crave a security which bars the gates to boldness. Cook said after the Bangladesh series that he worries for his men. Doesn’t he just. Too much. Let them experience the growing pains and the risk factor.
Rajkot might have been England’s real chance to catch a complacent India on the hop and put them on the back foot straight away. There’s talk of a psychological victory and momentum, which is all very well, but was the real intent to push for victory ever there?
The Scottish mountaineer and writer William Hutchison Murray once wrote: “Until one is committed, there is hesitancy, the chance to draw back, always ineffectiveness.”
To taste blood, you’ve got to smell it first. Alastair Cook is just way too nice to take a bite out of someone.
By Tim Ellis
Dan Lawrence shows early touch as Essex start strongly in Championship
There were big hundreds for Sam Robson, Tom Haines and James Vince.
Sachin Tendulkar thanks medical staff after returning home from hospital
Tendulkar was admitted to hospital last week after revealing he had tested positive for Covid-19 and had been in quarantine at home.
New Zealand name squad for their Test tour of England
New Zealand have named a 20-player squad for their tour of England, with three uncapped prospects in the group.
Jamie Porter hoping for England call after picking James Anderson’s brain
Porter was close to his England debut against India three years ago but has fallen down the pecking order.
ICC pressing ahead with plans for T20 World Cup in India despite Covid-19 spike
Acting chief executive Geoff Allardice says the ICC is “not anywhere near” activating any contingency plans.
Matt Parkinson takes positives from England tour despite lack of game time
Parkinson did not see competitive action in Sri Lanka or India.
Ponting sheds light on Smith’s Delhi Capitals role
Delhi Capitals coach Ricky Ponting has given some insight into where Steve Smith would fit into his side.
Akhtar ‘wouldn’t call De Kock a cheat’ but run-out not in the ‘spirit of cricket’
Shoaib Akhtar has had his say on Quinton de Kock’s controversial actions during the run-out of Fakhar Zaman.
Sarah Taylor set for playing comeback in The Hundred with Welsh Fire
Taylor put her cricketing career on hold in September 2019 when announcing her international retirement.