Opinion: ICC rules biased against bowlers
"I'm glad I'm not playing, because it is unfair to bowlers," says Waqar Younis on the state of the modern game, amidst a World Cup that is sure to inspire this generation of youngsters to spend a lot more time dreaming of being an international batsman than a bowler.
The records for the fastest fifty, century and 150 have all been broken in 2015 and flat pitches, especially in Australia, have dominated the proceedings at the 2015 World Cup. The average of the five highest totals in the 2011 World Cup was 355. In this edition so far it is 396.
A score of 400 was a statistical outlier, now it is the average at the top end. It is not as if the 2011 World Cup pitches were not designed for record breaking scores – I strongly believe that if this tournament were held there again then this trend would be no different.
The average run rate at the 2007 World Cup in the West Indies was 4,95 and across the subcontinent in 2011 it was 5.03. In the 2015 World Cup with only the knock outs of the tournament's 49 matches left to play, the average run rate is some 5.63 runs per over, which translates to an extra 30 runs per completed 50-over innings.
And most innings have indeed gone the distance because on these bowlers-graveyard surfaces, sides have found it far more difficult than ever to bowl out the opposition.
Australia used to have a reputation as a difficult place to get settled in with the bat, owing to the bouncy and often challenging decks, but the combination of changes to the game and the ICC’s perception that the television audience wants run-fests galore has led to a very high scoring and bland tournaments.
A high-scoring thriller is wonderful to see but sadly most of the first-innings high scores have resulted in landslide victories as chasing sides have crumbled in the pressure after losing early wickets.
Ironically, two of most entertaining two games of the tournament were New Zealand’s one-wicket win in chasing down 150 against Australia, and Afghanistan’s final-over one-wicket victory over Scotland chasing 211, with only three balls to spare.
Of course there are reasons for the high scores other than the flat pitches. Fielding restrictions in powerplays, free hits for no balls, improved bat technology and the increased invention of, and audacity to play, improvised strokes that were the reserve of Twenty20 cricket are factors that cannot be ignored in the ICC’s quest for runs of late.
Most of these changes were all in effect before the 2011 World Cup, but one rule (that had been trialled at the 1992 and 1996 World Cups) was only made a rule for all ODI’s later in 2011: two new balls – one from each end – are now used at every ODI.
The result is that the white ball, which would become soft and brown and harder to hit (and see) after 30 or 40 overs, stays virtually new. For a time the ball was replaced mandatorily with a slightly whiter one of a similar age after 34 overs.
Now the oldest, softest and most discoloured a ball can ever be is 25 overs and while it might seem an advantage to new ball bowlers upfront, the white balls these days appear engineered to hardly swing at all and lose their shine very quickly. The harder-for-longer and used-for-shorter white balls might just explain much of the fact that 350 was a winning score and now 400 is not entirely safe.
This ‘two-new-balls lead to higher scores’ theory is corroborated by the fact that the final 10 overs in the last World Cup resulted in an average of around 80 runs, while in this tournament the average score in the final 10 death overs is over 100 runs.
Day-night Test matches have not only been proposed, they might even begin within the next year. Matches are to be played with a pink ball that does not differ greatly from a white one.
While it is one thing experimenting with the limited-overs formats of the game, the fact that AB de Villiers could smash all records by walloping 149 runs in 44 balls with a white ball – outside of the Powerplay – might make a mockery of the records held by greats like Donald Bradman Garfield Sobers, and reduce the pure and wonderful contest of Test cricket to something similarly farcical.
I appreciate that India is the largest audience for the ICC and its designated broadcasters, and that Indian fans are more crazy about their side scoring a singles than they are about restricting the other side to dot balls (this sounds like a stereotype but listen to any Indian crowd and you will see what I mean).
The Indian market simply loves runs and runs are what they will get. Who pays the piper calls the tune and it may also be no coincidence that the Indian side who has struggled Down Under on lively pitches made by Cricket Australia have been making hay in the World Cup on flat pitches made by the ICC.
Boris Johnson sympathises with Ollie Robinson after ‘over the top’ suspension
Robinson has been suspended over historical tweets but the Prime Minister agreed with Oliver Dowden’s assessment the ECB has gone ‘over the top’.
Ollie Robinson given no assurances about England future after investigation
The seamer issued an apology for racist and sexist tweets he posted in 2012 and 2013 that were shared online on the day he made his Test bow.
Culture Secretary Oliver Dowden: Ollie Robinson’s punishment over the top
Robinson has been suspended from all international cricket pending the outcome of a disciplinary investigation.
England take safety-first approach to ensure first Test ends in draw at Lord’s
Dominic Sibley scored an unbeaten 60 to guide the home side to a share of the spoils.
England seamer Ollie Robinson suspended pending investigation into tweets
Tweets containing racist and sexist terms were sent on the bowler’s account in 2012 and 2013.
Joe Root admits there was never a ‘realistic opportunity’ for England victory
New Zealand skipper Kane Williamson tried to tempt England in the final two sessions by declaring during lunch, setting a victory target of 273.
Yorkshire secure dramatic victory over Sussex to remain in race for the title
Four wickets from Dom Bess helped the Tykes eventually break the resistance of the visitors’ lower order.
England hold on for draw in first Test against New Zealand at Lord’s
A grandstand finish failed to materialise and the series heads to Edgbaston all square.
England 56 for two chasing 273 on final day of first Test against New Zealand
The Lord’s encounter looks to be heading for a draw.
New Zealand up the ante at Lord’s as England face a challenging target
The tourists are likely to declare at some point this afternoon to leave England the probability of batting to save the Test.