DCMS chair Julian Knight levels ‘victim blaming’ accusation at Yorkshire
Yorkshire have been accused of “victim blaming” Azeem Rafiq in their investigation into his allegations of racism and bullying.
ESPN reported detail it said was contained in the county’s report on Monday, including the fact that a player repeatedly referred to Rafiq as a “P***”.
Despite that the panel did not uphold this allegation, with ESPN reporting the panel found Rafiq used the word “Zimbo” when referring to a player of Zimbabwean heritage.
In the section of the report summary, published by Yorkshire on September 10, which concerned this allegation, it stated: “The panel did not find Azeem Rafiq’s evidence wholly credible and did not uphold these allegations concluding that both Azeem and the player engaged in friendly verbal attack towards each other, and no malice was intended by either to the other.
“The panel concluded Azeem Rafiq and his team-mate’s language towards each other was unacceptable and was racist and derogatory.
“The panel found that this highlighted the importance of YCCC monitoring the use of such language and taking appropriate action against those individuals who engage in such comments, even if it is in the context of ‘banter’ or ‘friendly’.”
Julian Knight, the chair of the Digital, Culture, Media and Sport (DCMS) committee, was astonished by Yorkshire’s position.
He told the Today Programme: “There is a degree of victim blaming in the leaked report, where they equate Rafiq using ‘Zim’ for Zimbabwean as the same as the P-word. It is not the same.
“The idea of them using that as victim-blaming or to excuse their actions is absolutely appalling.”
Knight calls Yorkshire to account for racism allegations
The committee announced on Tuesday that Yorkshire chairman Roger Hutton had been called before it to give evidence on its handling of Rafiq’s allegations, and it is understood Rafiq himself and other members of the county hierarchy have also been invited.
The hearing is understood to be happening within a fortnight.
Knight added: “We want to get the lead people at Yorkshire County Cricket Club in front of us and we want to ask them how they can justify not having taken action and why it is they think that those who have used this language in their club are fit to still remain in their club, and what are they going to do in the future in order to ensure that Yorkshire gets a handle on this racism problem.”
Knight was asked if he was surprised that Yorkshire had said no one would face disciplinary action over the allegations Rafiq had made.
“Dumbfounded. I like to think I’m a fair employer but if anyone in my office used the P-word in any context, but particularly in this context, their feet wouldn’t touch the floor as they left the office,” he said.
Health secretary Sajid Javid said on Tuesday that “heads should roll” at Yorkshire as political pressure mounted.
The report commissioned by Yorkshire found Rafiq, who played for his home county in two stints between 2008 and 2018, had been a victim of “racial harassment and bullying” but did not find that Yorkshire as a club were institutionally racist.
In all, the report upheld just seven of 43 allegations Rafiq made.
The England and Wales Cricket Board (ECB) is conducting its own regulatory process having been sent a copy of Yorkshire’s report, which it hopes to conclude “as quickly as possible”.
Ajaz Patel savours ‘special day’ despite New Zealand collapse in Mumbai
Ajaz Patel will never forget 4 December 2021.
Former England seamer and Test cricket icon Eileen Ash dies aged 110
Ash made her Test debut against Australia in 1937.
Big Bash League
The dozen English stars you don’t want to miss in Australia’s Big Bash League
England’s dashing dozen are set to dazzle downunder.
Ajaz Patel joins elite club as he bags all ten wickets in India’s first innings
Ajaz Patel joins Jim Laker and Anil Kumble on the pedestal.
Justin Langer still haunted by Ben Stokes’ Headingley heroics but welcomes his return
The all-rounder produced the performance of a lifetime when the sides faced each other on English soil two-and-a-half years ago.
Second Test: India vs New Zealand – Day two – Scoreboard
Follow India vs New Zealand.
Second Test: Bangladesh vs Pakistan – Day one – Scoreboard
Follow Bangladesh vs Pakistan live!
Shaheen Afridi relishes his Pakistan new-ball partnership with Hasan Ali
Shaheen Afridi has 44 Test wickets to his name this year while Hasan Ali has 39.
Virat Kohli dismissal sparks furious debate over TV umpires and DRS
Virat Kohli fumes as TV umpires makes questionable call.
On this day in cricket history: Muttiah Muralitharan breaks Test wickets world record
The all-time great Sri Lanka off-spinner reached the landmark by bowling Paul Collingwood in the first Test against England in Kandy.