Opinion: ODIs should be put out to pasture
Guest columnist Peter Miller argues that Tests are perfectly safe, but ODIs are in danger of being even more irrelevant than they already are and should probably be retired.
We have seen one of the truly exhilarating run chases this week, in Jaipur. India stormed to victory against Australia chasing down 360 runs in with 39 balls to spare.
As Dhawan, Rohit Sharma and Kohli treated the Australian bowling like an all-you-can-eat buffet with a time limit, all you could do was gasp. But despite this occasional glimpse of the remarkable, it is not often that a One Day International sparks to life.
Much has been made over the last few years about the threat Twenty20 cricket is posing to Test matches. They say that in a time-poor age where people want quick fixes we will lose interest in the five-day game.
It seems that it is the wrong format that people are worried for. Since Test cricket began 145 years ago very little has changed. Two teams of 11 players have played two innings over a period of several days.
Compare this with the sick man of cricket: One Day Internationals. The 50-over games tacked on to the end of the recent Ashes is a prime example of how the game is viewed by administrators in England. A second string side played uninspired cricket. It was clear that it was more important to give fringe players a go at international level that to win the series.
Rightly or wrongly, The Ashes is where it is at for English cricket, but even in other countries there is a malaise growing about these games. Ask an Indian fan how excited they are about another ODI against Sri Lanka and you will not get an enthusiastic response.
Since the format began in the English county game with the Gillette Cup in 1963 it has undergone more shake ups than a struggling Government's Cabinet. It started as a 65 overs a side game, and in the intervening period One Day cricket in England has been played in games with innings lasting 60, 55, 50, 45 and 40 overs.
It has not been a gradual reduction in overs, but instead a move up and down on a sliding scale.
For the 2010/11 Australian domestic season there was an experiment with having split innings One Day games where there the teams batted for 20 and then 25 overs. This lasted just one year and the Ryobi Cup was back to 50 overs a side for the 2011/12 series.
It has not just been the length of the game that has been altered. In One Day International tournaments there are constant changes in the playing conditions. There have been compulsory catchers, a 30 yard fielding circle, compulsory Power Plays, batting Power Plays and bowling Power Plays.
The use of full substitutes was introduced in July 2005 for a 10 month trial where teams were allowed to tactically change the side with a player that was allowed to bat and bowl. This change lasted for just nine months before teams began to rebel against it. After Australia and South Africa agreed to play a series where the rule was not applied in March 2006 it was ditched by the ICC.
The use of two new balls was introduced for the 1996 World Cup and dropped again a short time later. This same rule was reintroduced in October 2011 in the hope of liven up the game. The two new ball rule is now under threat.
The Indian cricketing authorities have started campaigning against this change on behalf of the 'Asian block'. Their argument is that the role of spinners has been reduced as a result of this playing condition.
The opening 15 overs have been far more interesting with a new ball from each end as batsmen struggle to get themselves set and look to keep wickets in hand, but why should that get in the way of tinkering with the rules again?
Perhaps the solution to all this tinkering is to be more radical. Maybe a five-over 'Multiball' period where runs count for double, or the option for the batting side to release a tiger into the field at their time of choosing.
Despite all these changes the issue remains that while Twenty20 cricket lacks subtlety and ebb and flow, One Day formats become formulaic regardless of what changes administrators have implemented.
After building a strong base in the opening overs, teams milk the opposition bowling at around four an over in the hope of keeping wickets in hand to have a dash at the death. The constant alterations to try and change this are as futile as attempting to explain the LBW law to Stuart Broad and Imran Tahir.
All the meddling in the playing conditions does is confuse the viewing public while not adding any more excitement to a format that is becoming rapidly outdated. The only thing that 50 over cricket gives you that Twenty20 cricket doesn't is more opportunities for the broadcasters to have advert breaks.
With constant complaints from players and administrators that it is difficult to fit matches into the calendar perhaps an obvious, all be it radical, solution is staring us in the face. One Day cricket has been great for the game, but it could well be time to put it out to pasture.
<b>Peter Miller (@TheCricketGeek)</b>
Ben Stokes looking forward to Liam Livingstone’s Test debut for England
Livingstone has not played a red-ball match in 2022.
James Anderson: England ‘chomping at the bit’ to start first Test in Pakistan
The 40-year-old is the only member of the England squad to have toured the country before.
Kisma News: India need more pace, bowling all-rounders
The Indian cricket team is amidst a rebuild of sorts after a disappointing T20 World Cup. The focus is to bring new talent into the team…
Brendon McCullum has no issues with Liam Livingstone’s lack of red-ball cricket
Livingstone has built his name as a prolific limited-overs performer.
Brendon McCullum vows England will continue to entertain in Pakistan
England won six out of seven Tests playing an attacking brand of cricket over the summer.
Kisma News: India’s decision to persist with Rishabh Pant is admirable, but his failures are mounting
Rishabh Pant’s form in white-ball cricket has been the subject of intense scrutiny – and with good reason too…
On this day in 2012: Ashley Giles appointed England limited-overs head coach
Giles’ tenure in the role only lasted 18 months.
Boost for aspiring black cricketers as ACE scheme launches in northern England
The programme is a partnership between Yorkshire, the Sheffield Caribbean Sports Club and African Caribbean Engagement (ACE).
England arrive in Pakistan for first Test tour since 2005
Only James Anderson was there when England last played Tests and one-day internationals in Pakistan.
Kisma News: Hardik Pandya’s reasoning for excluding Umran Malik and Sanju Samson
Going into the T20I series against New Zealand, most Indian fans expected bench players would be given more significant opportunities…