Stewart: Seriously consider dropping Swann

Former England captain Alec Stewart feels coach Andy Flower should consider the almost sacrilegious idea of dropping spinner Graeme Swann for the third Ashes Test in Perth, starting on Friday.
Former England captain Alec Stewart feels coach Andy Flower should consider the almost sacrilegious idea of dropping spinner Graeme Swann for the third Ashes Test in Perth, starting on Friday.
The WACA pitch is far more conducive to fast bowling, and with Swann and Monty Panesar failing to impress in the first two matches, which Australia won, a growing feeling is that England could go with an all pace attack and add a batsman.
Stewart said on <i>The Ashes Breakfast</i> in the wake of the Adelaide defeat: "England have got to look at the make-up of the team. Are they going to go in with just one spinner and will that be Swann or Panesar?
"Previously it was always going to be Swann but he is averaging 99 in the two Tests and is going at more than four an over with a strike-rate of about 140 balls per wicket.
"You could go in without a spinner and just have Joe Root and Kevin Pietersen as the back-up. It's a brave decision but I think England have to do something slightly different. To leave Graeme Swann out of an England team is almost unheard of."
Stewart then went on to say that leaving Swann out was also a risk in terms of the slip cordon, but that if nothing else, it was the batting department that needed the most attention.
He added: "You do leave yourself a little bit open if you leave a spinner out but it will definitely be something that the selectors will discuss.
"England have backed themselves very much on the continuity of selection but they haven't been in this position – 2-0 down – for a very, very long time.
"It's the batting that has fallen by the wayside and they've got to look at that. Are they going to forego a spinner to lengthen the batting and play four out-and-out seamers?
"Swann is probably England's best slip fielder. If he didn't play, then who is going to stand at second slip? These are the types of conundrums the selectors will look at.
"Whatever they do they have to make sure that the players believe they can win because, as Alastair Cook said, if you don't believe you might as well pack your bags and go home now."
Latest
-
News
Ollie Robinson and Dom Sibley get chance to push Test claims in County Select XI
The duo, who have 31 international caps between them, will be hoping to make an impression against New Zealand.
-
News
England’s new dawn and Commonwealth Games – cricket’s summer highlights
The Hundred returns for a second season while India return to finish last summer’s Test series.
-
News
Zak Crawley ready to raise his game for England
The batter has made a modest start to the county season.
-
News
Zak Crawley rediscovers form as Kent’s clash with Northamptonshire is drawn
Crawley started the week averaging under 20 in this season’s LV= Insurance County Championship.
-
News
India recall Cheteshwar Pujara for rescheduled Test against England
The 34-year-old has scored four hundreds in eight innings for Sussex this season.
-
News
Keith Barker blows away Somerset to help Hampshire to victory
The visitors needed just one run in their second innings to seal victory.
-
News
Craig Overton claims 400th first-class wicket in Somerset-Hampshire clash
The England seamer’s three-wicket burst left the contest delicately balanced at the halfway stage.
-
News
Three positive Covid tests confirmed in New Zealand’s tour party
Batter Henry Nicholls, seamer Blair Tickner and bowling coach Shane Jurgensen will self-isolate for five days.
-
News
Zak Crawley outdone by Ben Compton as Kent start strongly at Northamptonshire
Opener Compton stole the show with an unbeaten 125.
-
News
Mark Wood admits frustration over slow progress from elbow surgery
Wood is targeting a Test return towards the back end of the summer.