There is no-one to blame for Hughes’ death
The New South Wales coroner’s inquest into Australia batsman Phillip Hughes’ death has been described as a ‘witch hunt’ and looking at the coverage, it’s tough to argue otherwise.
Hughes died nearly two years ago after being struck on the neck by a bouncer bowled by NSW Blues paceman Sean Abbott. It caused an instant brain haemorrhage, and he passed away two days later.
The inquest (held in cases of unexpected or unnatural deaths), which started at the NSW coroner’s court this week, has seen the likes of Brad Haddin questioned about his side’s bowling tactics, and Doug Bollinger forced to defend his sledging.
Kristina Sterns, council for the coroner, said: “Concerns have been raised in relation to the number of short balls that were delivered by the pace bowlers to Phillip Hughes. And as to tactics during the afternoon session that day.
“In particular, concern has been expressed that the NSW team may have been bowling short at Phillip Hughes for a good majority of the time after lunch, in order to restrict the run rate and get him out. And as to whether the umpires should have taken steps to prevent this.”
But one has to wonder what the point is of dragging these players, and the Hughes family, through all this in a search to find someone, or something, to blame. The line of questioning seems to target the players, rather than to find a way to make the game safer.
The inquest has already heard that Hughes’ death was ‘inevitable’ and that nothing, no matter how fast the ambulance had reached him, could have saved him from such a freak accident. Using one of the new, safer batting helmets would not have saved him either.
So questioning Bollinger, who denied telling Hughes, ‘I’m going to kill you’, seems fruitless and prolonging of the agony. As it was, Bollinger did not bowl the fatal ball, so it’s irrelevant what he said in the heat of battle.
And even if Abbott, who was understandably devastated by the events, had said those words, bringing it up now implies intent, that he meant to do harm, which is a ludicrous thing to think.
One must, of course, keep the family in mind. Finding someone to blame in your grief is natural, we’ve seen it time and again, and empathy is easy to come by.
The court heard that Jason Hughes, Phillip’s brother, had compiled a presentation to show how many short balls were bowled to his brother that day, as he looked to find a reason for the accident.
Sterns added: “Jason Hughes has, with the benefit of the video footage available, prepared a ball by ball analysis of the short-pitched deliveries that will assist your honour in understanding these issues.”
You can imagine the grief-stricken man sitting in front of game footage, over and over again, noting each short ball, down to the tragic final bouncer, looking for anything to explain what happened.
But skippers the world over use short deliveries against batsmen vulnerable to them. Barrages of bouncers are bowled every day, and the percentage that do harm are miniscule. That tiny percentage includes Hughes.
Can you blame Brad Haddin for setting a field to try and get Hughes out on the hook or pull? Or Sean Abbott for using a delivery so effective in the past? Should bouncers be banned altogether? No.
The changes that have been made since the accident are out in full force, from neck protectors to new helmets, to stricter umpiring. It’s reactionary, of course, but how could this have been foreseen by anyone?
The point of an inquest is to find out what could have been done to prevent the death in question, and how it could be prevented in future. We knew the answers to those questions already.
Lindsay du Plessis
T20 World Cup 2022
Kisma News: T20 World Cup 2022: Which Asian team has the greatest chance at the World Cup?
The eighth edition of the T20I World Cup is starting in the next 13 days, with Australia entering the tournament as defending champions…
‘Sorry, I’m done’ – Moeen Ali closes door on possible return to Test cricket
The 35-year-old retired from the longest format last year but hinted in June that he could be tempted back under the guidance of Brendon McCullum.
England’s Jonny Bairstow rules himself out of T20 World Cup due to injury
The 33-year-old is unsure when he will be fit to return.
Jasprit Bumrah ruled out of India’s Twenty20 World Cup squad
Bumrah is one of the leading seam bowlers in world cricket and his absence is a major setback to India.
Matthew Mott ‘close’ to knowing England’s first-choice World Cup Twenty20 team
The head coach has hinted hint that Harry Brook has forced his way in following the series win in Pakistan.
Teams will fear us – Moeen Ali turns attention to T20 World Cup after series win
England beat Pakistan in the deciding seventh T20 in Lahore.
England finish with a flourish in Lahore to wrap up T20 series win over Pakistan
Dawid Malan led the way with an unbeaten 78 as the tourists won the decider in the seven-match series by 67 runs.
Dawid Malan shines as England set Pakistan 210 to win Twenty20 series decider
Harry Brook added an unbeaten 46 as England made 209 for three in Lahore.
David Saker backs England bowlers to make splash at Twenty20 World Cup
He has been working closely with the team over the course of an entertaining back-and-forth series.
Phil Salt grateful for England backing after starring in big win over Pakistan
The opener had scored just 59 runs in his first five innings on tour but blazed 87 not out to guide England to victory over Pakistan on Friday.